Crossing Over-Thank You, Dick Dobson, for the Reminder

By most measures, Dick Dobson should be about 150 years old. He’s got some hard miles on him, but at 81 he’s still got his memory and his health, and at that age, you can’t ask for much more.

For those of you who don’t remember him, Dobson is the former editor and publisher of the Minot Daily News, and probably knows more about North Dakota politics than anyone alive. He befriended me back in the 1980s when I was executive director of the North Dakota Democratic-NPL Party and we’ve stayed in touch over the years—just barely.

He’s retired now and living with his son in Fargo. He reads the Fargo Forum but not the Minot Daily News. It was a darn good paper when he ran it, but it isn’t any more.  I could tell you a few stories about him but he wouldn’t like that—not the ones I know.

His name showed up on my caller ID screen when my cell phone rang the other night. I answered “No shit, you’re still alive?” “Oh, so you’ve got that caller identification,” he replied.

After a brief bit of small talk, reassuring each other that we were alive and pretty well, he launched into his reason for calling. “They’re saying you had something to do with the Democrats crossing over in the Primary Election last week. Do you remember the 1968 Primary?”

I confessed that I didn’t—I was in the Navy at the time. I was arriving in Pensacola Florida about the time of the September Primary, and I wasn’t old enough to vote yet—I was two days short of my 21st birthday on the day of the September 3 Primary. I did vote by absentee ballot in the General Election a couple months later, though, the first election in which I was eligible to vote. I remember voting for Hubert Humphrey for President of the United States. He got trounced by Richard Nixon, both in North Dakota and nationally.

But it was the 1968 Primary Dobson wanted to talk about. “Tell me the story,” I said. He did.

The Republican Party that year nominated newspaper publisher Ed Doherty from New Rockford as their candidate for governor. Bismarck auto dealer and political maverick Robert McCarney challenged him in the Primary Election. As Dobson tells it, Larry Erickson, chairman of the North Dakota Democratic-NPL Party, sent out a press release urging Democrats to cross over and vote for McCarney, because Democrats felt he would be easier for Democrat Bill Guy to defeat in the fall.

It worked. McCarney beat Doherty by a little over 4,000 votes, 47,000-43,000. Incumbent Democratic-NPL Governor Bill Guy got about 33,000 votes. About 90,000 voters cast ballots in the Republican Governor’s race. By comparison, Senator Milton Young got 82,000 votes and the Republican Congressional candidates got about 84,000. Erickson claimed victory.

In the fall, Guy beat McCarney by more than 25,000 votes, in spite of the fact that Richard Nixon beat Hubert Humphrey from neighboring Minnesota by almost 45,000 votes. Guy, running in his last election for governor, actually got more votes than Nixon. And Guy was the only Democratic-NPL-endorsed candidate to win election in a North Dakota statewide race that year. Republicans won race s for U.S. Senate, both seats in Congress (North Dakota had two Congressmen until the 1970 census took one away), Attorney General, Agriculture Commissioner, Treasurer, Insurance Commissioner, Public Service Commissioner, Secretary of State and Auditor.

Guy’s re-election was fortuitous. It changed North Dakota politics in a big way, because of the chaotic state of the North Dakota Tax Commissioner’s office in the 1960s. At the time, the Tax Commissioner was elected on the no-party ballot (it remained there until North Dakota voters changed the State Constitution in 1986). In 1960, Arthur Engen had been elected Tax Commissioner, but he died in office in 1963, and Governor Guy appointed a Democrat, Lloyd Omdahl, who at the time was Guy’s administrative assistant (Omdahl later served as Lieutenant Governor of North Dakota under George Sinner) to the office. Omdahl won election in 1964, but resigned to return to Guy’s staff in 1966, and Guy appointed another Democrat, Ed Sjaastad, to the post.

Sjaastad was elected to a full term as Tax Commissioner in 1968 on the no-party ballot, in the same election Guy beat McCarney, but just a few months into his term, he committed suicide in his office in the spring of 1969, giving Guy the opportunity to make his third appointment to that office. He chose a young MBA graduate from Regent, North Dakota named Byron Dorgan. You know the rest of the story. Well, just in case you don’t . . .

Dorgan went on to become one of North Dakota’s most popular politicians. He won election to the office of Tax Commissioner in 1972, was re-elected in 1976, was elected to Congress in 1980, was elected to the U.S. Senate in 1992, and retired in 2010. He did lose one election in that more-than-40- year career, ironically the same year Guy lost his only statewide election, in 1974.

That story goes like this. Guy had left office in 1972 to prepare for a 1974 U.S. Senate race against incumbent Senator Milton Young, turning the Governor’s chair over to Art Link. The Democrats endorsed him for Senate at their 1974 convention. Knowing that Guy had a real chance of beating Young, who had held the seat since 1945 but had never really been threatened, Republicans decided to try the crossover strategy Democrats had used in 1968. McCarney filed as a Democrat in the Primary against Guy, and urged Republicans to cross over and steal the nomination from Guy.

It didn’t work. Democrats, led by Guy’s campaign manager, a young political genius named David Strauss, put together the state’s first sophisticated Get-Out-The-Vote program for the Primary, and Democrats turned out in big numbers to hold the slot for Guy.  More than 50,000 Democrats turned out to vote for Guy. McCarney managed to persuade only about 11,000 Republicans to cross over and vote for him in the Democratic-NPL column.

Meanwhile, because of Dorgan’s popularity, Guy had persuaded Dorgan to run with him that year as the opponent to Republican Congressman Mark Andrews. Together they were a formidable team at the top of the ticket. Not formidable enough. A third-party challenger in the Young-Guy race, James Jungroth, foiled Guy’s plans. Jungroth, a known Democrat and former Democratic-NPL Party chairman, had some personal differences with Guy, and the more-than 6,000 votes he got in November threw the election to Young by just a couple hundred votes out of more than 235,000 cast. Dorgan was soundly defeated by Andrews, but that story got lost in all the attention paid to the Senate race. Dorgan would just as soon have it forgotten anyway, since it was his only defeat ever at the polls in North Dakota.

Dobson brought all this to my attention with his fortuitous call this week. Democrats crossed over to vote for McCarney over the Republican-endorsed candidate in the 1968 Primary, McCarney won, Guy beat McCarney in the General, enabling Dorgan’s career. And there’s more. Dorgan hired a young fellow named Kent Conrad as his chief assistant in the Tax Department. Conrad succeeded Dorgan as Tax Commissioner and then served 26 years in the U. S. Senate. Conrad hired a young law school graduate named Heidi Heitkamp as the Tax Department’s lawyer. She succeeded him as Tax Commissioner when he went to the Senate in 1986, served six years there, then eight years as Attorney General, and is now four years into her first term in the U.S. Senate.

All that because Larry Erickson told his Democrats to cross over and vote for Republican Robert McCarney in the 1968 Primary.

I never heard Larry Erickson take credit for the political success of Dorgan, Conrad or Heitkamp, but he probably should have. Larry died two years ago next month. He’d have loved the outcome of this year’s Primary Election. He’d have crossed over and voted for Doug Burgum. He knew something about that.

15 thoughts on “Crossing Over-Thank You, Dick Dobson, for the Reminder

  1. Jim,
    Great story from the inside. Enjoy your blog.

    Inform me and a lot of us middle of the road voters what happened to the Democratic Party since then? They do not win local elections, county elections or statewide let alone national representation except for Heide. During that time I would vote for the candidate not the party. Still would, where are those individuals that draw all of us together. Interesting world when I see individuals I know, like you, that cannot believe the opposition can do anything right.

    Just tell me how you will solve our problems without degrading the opposition. Sick of not giving me solutions and ideas to solve problems. Where are the individuals that can sit down, talk it over face to face and give us solutions. Seems easy to tell people what I can do for you as an elected person but no one is telling us what we should do for the better of all. Look at our choices for President????


    1. Middle of the road voters? The only thing you’ll find in the middle of the road (to paraphrase former Texas Agriculture Commissioner Jim Hightower)is yellow lines and dead skunks.


  2. A great story—at least for our generation. This is the period after Bill Guy and a group of dedicated NPL Dems built the modern democratic party into a powerful and functional political force and it helped our state in a lot of ways. As history reminds us, all good things must come to an end.

    The tax commissioner story is of particular interest to me. It began with Ed Sjaastad story. He had been suffering for many days and his bizarre behavior frightened most in his office and beyond. Too scared to take any action, Ed finally shot himself. The interesting story is what happened next and how a number of ND political figures debated as just how to handle the situation. It is the stuff of movies. It, in part let to the Jungroth campaign and to a downward spiral of the Democratic party.

    Of course, history is in the eyes of the beholder. From my perspective, from that point through today, the Democratic party has concentrated on the State’s Washington corp and little my little have regarded State or Legislative offices as less important. Opinion? Maybe. But the proof is in the pudding. How many Democrats serve at the Capitol today? How has that sad fact affected how our State has been run since 1992? Does anyone think a 1 party rule is working?

    It is interesting at how relatively obscure events can have such long term impact on our world.

    This could be the year when the Democratic party rebuilds from the ground up. The State needs it even more that the Party.


  3. and 4 years later, 1972, Buckshot Hoffner beat Ed Doherty for his Senate Seat effectively putting an end to Ed’s career in North Dakota politics.


  4. The difference between that period and today is the extent to which Republicans are mounting efforts to limit voter participation. First, the Voter ID law. Next, the forthcoming proposal for a closed primary.
    My hope is that the Republicans are short-cited enough to propose a blanket primary ( That way, the voters get their two preferred candidates regardless of party.


  5. Thank you Jim for a really wonderful story. Our family remembers these great tales and our Dad’s passion for Dem/NPL politics. Miss him every single day and the decisively appropriate things he’d have to say. By the way, I worked for Dick for several years. I would love to have his contact info.


  6. Although Nixon won by over 100 electoral votes his margin over Humphrey in the popular vote was less than 1 percent. Not a trouncing for sure.

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s